What Are “Dark Social” and the “Dark Funnel”?

‍

Dark Social refers to traffic that comes from private or untrackable channels – for example, when someone shares a link via a messaging app, email, or a private social media group. These visits typically show up as “direct” traffic in analytics because no referrer data is passed. In fact, a 2023 GlobalWebIndex study found 65% of social sharing happens through dark social channels (like WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Instagram DMs), which means a huge portion of content dissemination is essentially invisible to standard tracking. One content analytics report indicated that up to 70% of what analytics labels as “direct traffic” is actually coming from dark social sharing (especially on mobile). These “hidden” shares aren’t just numerous – they’re highly effective. Research by RadiumOne showed content shared through dark social converts 4–5 times more than content shared on public, trackable platforms. In other words, the most valuable social referrals often leave zero trail in your web analytics.

Dark Funnel is a related concept, often used in B2B marketing, describing all the buyer touchpoints and research that happen outside of your visible marketing funnel. It’s “dark” because the brand has no direct line of sight into these interactions. Prospects today educate themselves via word-of-mouth, private communities, third-party content, and AI-driven sources without ever clicking a tracked ad or visiting your blog during those early stages. One CEO noted that many prospects now “materialize at the bottom of our funnel, ready to buy – having somehow bypassed every carefully planned touchpoint”. In reality, they were influenced by the dark funnel (peers, forums, review sites, social media discussions, etc.), but from the marketer’s perspective these users seem to appear out of nowhere. The traditional linear funnel (awareness → interest → consideration → purchase), where each stage could be tracked and nurtured, is being upended by a non-linear journey that largely happens in the shadows.

Are Traditional Marketing Funnels Dead?

Given this shift, marketers are asking if the classic funnel is “dead.” The funnel concept isn’t completely gone – people still move through awareness and consideration before buying – but our ability to observe and guide that journey has fundamentally decreased. In essence, the old funnel model is losing its reliability because so many touches happen off the radar. Buyers can jump from learning about a product in a private chat or AI recommendation straight to purchasing, without ever engaging in the trackable steps marketers set up. From the analytics viewpoint, it indeed looks like the funnel has “died” or at least gone dark.

For example, in B2B SaaS it’s common to see a large chunk of sign-ups or leads labeled as “direct traffic.” In one case, a company found about 30% of new sign-ups appeared as direct visits in Google Analytics. Only after interviewing those customers did they discover the real source: their product had been heavily discussed in a private Slack community for professionals. All those users were influenced by peer discussion (dark social) and came to the site directly, completely bypassing the trackable funnel. Stories like this illustrate how misleading funnel data can be – marketers might falsely assume those sign-ups were just organic or brand-aware visitors, missing the fact that a specific word-of-mouth channel was driving them.

So, are funnels dead? Traditional, linear funnels – as a planning and measurement framework – are largely obsolete in this dark social era. Users don’t follow a tidy path from one campaign touch to the next. Instead, they zigzag through online and offline touchpoints we can’t fully track, then often “convert” only when they’re already far along in their decision. This doesn’t mean marketers should abandon funnel thinking altogether, but it means we can’t rely on observed funnel metrics alone to understand our marketing performance. The funnel has effectively splintered into many micro-journeys, some visible and many invisible.

The Rise of Dark Traffic and Attribution Blind Spots

One immediate effect of the dark funnel world is the surge in “direct” traffic and other attribution blind spots in analytics. As more sharing and recommending happens in private, attribution reliability decreases. Analytics tools (especially those using last-click attribution) struggle to assign credit properly when a visitor’s true origin is hidden. Marketers end up scratching their heads over spikes in direct or unexplained traffic.

To appreciate how big this is, consider these findings:

• Private Sharing Dominates: 65% of all social content sharing is via private channels (messengers, email, text) rather than public social feeds. People increasingly share links directly with friends/colleagues because it feels more personal and secure. Each time they do, that link loses its referrer information and any marketer seeing the click just labels it “direct.” According to http://Parse.ly ’s data, the majority of so-called direct mobile traffic is actually from these untracked shares. We’re essentially in an era where “dark” referrals outnumber visible referrals for many businesses.
• Trust and Efficacy: Those dark social referrals often carry more weight. A link shared by a friend in a chat comes with context or endorsement, making it highly persuasive. No wonder conversion rates are several times higher for dark social traffic than for traffic from public social media. Private recommendations are perceived as 3X more trustworthy than public posts, studies show, which translates to better ROI from those hidden shares. The irony is that your most valuable traffic might be the least understood, because standard reports just lump it under “direct” or can’t tie it to a campaign.
• Examples of Hidden Attribution: Besides the Slack example above, think of scenarios like a WhatsApp group chat or an influencer’s private Facebook group. If someone shares your blog post or product link there, you might later see a flood of new sessions or sales with no attribution. One marketing agency noted a client’s huge traffic spike after a promotion; they discovered it was from a private Facebook group sharing a discount code – but initially it looked like an anomalous direct traffic bump. Without investigative work, these would be misattributed or not attributed at all.

All this leads to an attribution blind spot. Marketers may inadvertently undervalue channels that drive dark social influence. For instance, if a brand is getting many referrals from people sharing its content in Slack or Discord, the brand’s team might not realize it and thus “undervalue organic and word-of-mouth” contributions. Conversely, they might overvalue the last touch (like Google search or a retargeting ad) that simply caught the user after all the unseen research was done. This can lead to poor budget decisions – e.g., over-investing in the last-click channel and neglecting the content or community efforts that actually educated the customer.

AI Chats: A New Frontier of the Dark Funnel

On top of traditional dark social, we now have AI conversational assistants becoming the newest “dark funnel” channel. Large Language Model (LLM) AI systems – like ChatGPT, Bing Chat, Google’s Bard or SGE (Search Generative Experience) – are changing how people discover and evaluate products. Crucially, these AI-driven chats often leave no referral trail for marketers.

Imagine a scenario: a consumer asks an AI chat for a product recommendation instead of searching the web themselves. For example, “What’s a good affordable, energy-efficient dishwasher under $800?” The AI instantly summarizes reviews and specs and suggests a specific model. The user, trusting the AI, then goes to a retailer’s site or Google and searches directly for that product name to purchase it. From the brand’s perspective, that buyer appeared as a direct visit or organic search with no hint that an AI chatbot influenced the decision. The pivotal touchpoint – the AI’s recommendation – is completely invisible to the brand’s analytics.

This is not a one-off scenario; it’s rapidly becoming common. Millions of users are leveraging AI assistants daily for product research, comparisons, and recommendations. Key discovery stages that used to involve clicking around on blogs, review sites, or search results (which could be tracked via referrals, SEO, or ads) are now happening entirely within an AI chat interface. Microsoft has integrated AI (Copilot) into search, and Google is rolling out its generative AI search results – these blur the line between search and chat. Moreover, younger generations often bypass traditional Google searches, favoring answers from TikTok, Reddit, or AI – a generational shift in behavior that further expands the dark funnel.

From a tracking standpoint, AI chats are a black box. Marketers can’t put analytics scripts or pixels into an AI’s conversation. We can’t “see” the questions asked or the answers given about our brand. As one analysis put it, a significant (and growing) portion of the top-of-funnel and mid-funnel activity is occurring in environments where we “cannot place tracking pixels… or directly measure engagement.” When a customer finally lands on your site after an AI chat, traditional tools have no way to know about that prior AI-driven touch. It all shows up as direct traffic or self-attributed to whatever link they clicked last.

This AI-driven dark funnel exacerbates the attribution problem:

• Marketers risk misallocating resources because they might see, say, an increase in conversions and credit it to the wrong thing. For instance, sales of Product X might jump and you assume it was due to your recent ad campaign or a bump in search rankings – when in truth, an AI chatbot just started recommending your product more frequently due to some new data it ingested. If you don’t realize that, you might double down on the wrong marketing tactics and miss investing in the factors that actually caused the lift (like getting more positive reviews which influence the AI, in this example).
• The initial customer relationship might belong to the AI, not you. In the AI chat scenario, the user’s trust and information came from the AI’s voice. The brand doesn’t get to introduce itself, tell its story, or capture the user’s attention early on. This means marketers lose opportunities to differentiate or build an emotional connection during consideration. Also, if the product disappoints, the customer might even blame the AI’s recommendation more than the brand, which is a strange new dynamic to manage.
• Some traditional metrics can mislead in this new world. For example, you might see fewer visitors reading your long-form educational content or fewer ebook downloads, and assume interest is down or your content strategy is failing. But it could be that users are still consuming your information – just indirectly via AI summaries or third-party sites – and thus not hitting your tracked assets. If a CMO isn’t aware of this, they might cut back on content creation (thinking it’s wasted) when in fact that content is feeding the AI and influencing customers through the dark funnel. In short, a drop in web traffic or top-of-funnel leads does not necessarily mean your marketing failed; it might mean buyers got what they needed elsewhere in the dark funnel before coming to you.

In summary, the rise of AI-driven search and chat interfaces is pushing us further into a “dark world” of attribution – one where a critical part of the buyer’s decision process leaves virtually no data exhaust for us to track. Marketers’ control over the journey is indeed diminished: we can’t see or directly shape what the AI tells customers about us in those moments. As the user prompt suggested, “everything is going into the dark”, and as a result our traditional control as marketers is slipping.

Why This Matters for Marketers and CMOs

For marketing leaders (CMOs, growth leads, etc.), these trends pose serious challenges:

• Attribution Reliability Plummets: The more customer acquisition happens via dark social or AI, the less reliable our attribution models become. Last-click models were already problematic; now they can be completely blind. If you cannot attribute 30%, 40%, or more of your conversions properly, then calculating ROI by channel becomes a guessing game. This makes it hard to justify budgets – e.g., how much should we spend on social media or content – if the outcomes of those efforts hide in “direct” traffic stats. As one LinkedIn article noted, without a dark social attribution strategy, brands risk underestimating key marketing channels because those channels’ impact isn’t obvious in analytics.
• Misinterpreting Data: Marketers might draw the wrong conclusions. If you see a bunch of direct traffic converting, you might incorrectly credit your brand strength or offline efforts, when actually it was a specific Reddit thread or an AI recommendation driving those buyers. Conversely, you might see low measurable engagement on awareness campaigns and prematurely cut them, not realizing they succeeded in feeding the dark funnel which later led to sales. These blind spots can lead to misallocated spend – investing in what shows up (perhaps overly in branded search or retargeting ads) and under-investing in the higher-funnel activities that quietly generated the demand.
• Loss of Control and Confidence: CMOs and marketing managers are used to having data-driven control – tweaking campaigns based on clear metrics. In a dark funnel world, there’s a feeling of “suddenly our control is gone.” It’s disconcerting to know a big chunk of your customer’s journey is happening where you can’t observe or intervene. This can lead to pressure from executives: “Why is our attribution so poor?” or “Where are these sales really coming from?” Marketers have to answer with less certainty, often educating stakeholders about the existence of dark social and AI influences.
• The Need for New Skills and KPIs: The situation forces marketing teams to broaden how they gauge success. Instead of just funnel metrics like CPA (cost per acquisition) per channel or conversion rates per campaign, teams must monitor things like brand search volume, direct traffic trends, and even qualitative buzz. The KPIs that matter might become more about overall share-of-voice in online conversations or improvements in customer self-reported attribution (“heard about us from a friend/AI/etc.”) rather than purely last-click ROI. This is a paradigm shift for data-driven teams.
• Competitive Implications: If your company fails to adapt to the dark funnel, you might lose out to competitors who do. For instance, if a competitor’s product is systematically recommended by AI assistants over yours because they invested in educating the AI (with content, schema markup, etc.), they will capture those invisible leads. Similarly, brands who actively encourage and facilitate private sharing (and glean insights from it) will have an edge over those still stuck on traditional funnel marketing. In short, adaptation becomes a competitive necessity.

At this point, it’s clear that the marketing funnel hasn’t so much died as it has gone underground. The task now is figuring out how to measure and influence an environment where visibility is limited. In the next section, we’ll explore solutions – how do we measure attribution when traffic is coming from dark sources like AI chats, and what strategies can marketers use to thrive in this “dark world.”

Strategies to Measure and Adapt in a Dark Funnel World

Even if we can’t fully illuminate every dark touchpoint, there are several ways marketers can adapt their measurement and strategy to this new reality. The key is accepting that traditional tracking will never be 100% and combining multiple approaches – both quantitative and qualitative, both technical and strategic (i.e., “both” sides of the equation need attention).

Here are some tactics and solutions:

1. Accept and Embrace the New Reality

First, it’s a mindset shift. Acknowledge that some user journeys will remain untrackable and plan for success without perfect data. Chasing every data point isn’t feasible when it goes against privacy or technical limits. Instead, focus on influencing those unseen decisions. One expert advises treating a positive mention in an AI chat or a private forum kind of like you would a good PR placement – you know it drives awareness even if you can’t directly tie it to sales. In practice, this means:

• Keep creating content and experiences that you suspect are working via dark channels, even if the direct attribution isn’t there. For instance, if many customers say they heard about you from “a friend” or “online communities,” invest in referral programs or community engagement, trusting that these will pay off over time (supported by correlation data, if not direct tracking).
• Align your team and leadership on new metrics of success (more on those below) so that everyone understands why, for example, an uptick in direct traffic and branded search could be celebrated as a win (indicating strong word-of-mouth), rather than dismissed as “untrackable.”

In short, shift from lamenting what you can’t track to doubling down on what you can influence.

2. Strengthen What Can Be Tracked (Technical Solutions)

While you can’t track everything, you can improve tracking within reason. Implementing a robust attribution infrastructure will capture a portion of dark social activity and at least tag some of those “direct” visitors with their true source:

• UTM and Link Tagging Strategy: Deploy comprehensive UTM parameters for links, especially for content likely to be shared. This includes adding UTM codes to the URLs you share on social and encouraging employees/fans to use those URLs. According to a 2024 B2B marketing report, brands with structured UTM systems achieved up to 31% more accurate social attribution data than those without. The idea is to generate unique, memorable short links for different channels (e.g., a special URL for a specific webinar or whitepaper) so that even if someone copy-pastes it in a private chat, the UTM travels with it. You won’t catch everything, but you’ll shed light on some formerly dark shares.
• Specialized Tracking Tools: Use tools designed to catch dark social sharing. For example, URL shorteners with analytics (like Bitly, Rebrandly) can show you how many clicks came from a copied link, even if those clicks had no referrer. Similarly, share button widgets (AddThis, ShareThis, etc.) not only encourage sharing but also record that a share action happened, even if the actual follow-up visit is direct. These give you at least an idea that “Content X was copied/shared 500 times,” which you can infer is driving direct traffic later.
• “Dark-to-Light” Bridge Campaigns: Some advertising formats specifically try to bridge public and private channels. For instance, Meta (Facebook) offers “Click-to-Message” ads – an ad that, when clicked, opens a chat in Messenger or WhatsApp with your business. This way, a user’s journey moves from a public click (trackable) to a private conversation, but you as an advertiser know the conversation starter and can attribute outcomes to it. It’s not a perfect science, but it helps capture at least the entry into dark social. If that user later converts, you have a thread to trace it back to the ad that opened the chat. Using these kinds of ad products can maintain attribution where normally it would be lost once the user goes private.
• AI-Based Traffic Analysis: Leverage advanced analytics that use machine learning to identify patterns in “direct” traffic. Newer analytics platforms are introducing AI features to guess likely sources of unattributed visits. For example, Adobe Analytics’ 2024 update has an AI “Source Recognition” system that claims to correctly identify up to 40% of previously uncategorized dark social traffic by analyzing things like visiting patterns, user agent strings, etc.. While we should take such claims with a grain of salt, these tools can probabilistically attribute some direct traffic to sources (e.g., recognizing that a surge in direct visits to a certain landing page likely came from a popular Reddit thread based on timing and user profiles).
• Multi-Touch and Mix Modeling: Since single-touch attribution is less trustworthy, adopt a multi-touch attribution model or even marketing mix modeling. Multi-touch attribution (MTA) looks at the sequence of touches for each conversion to give partial credit to all known interactions. It can reveal “assist” channels. For instance, an MTA might show that even though many conversions ended with direct traffic, a common earlier touch for those users was an untracked social click or an organic search – indicating an upstream influence. (Salesforce found that using path analysis, marketers could identify ~2.7 additional touchpoints per conversion on average, often including dark social touches that last-click missed.) Meanwhile, Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM) doesn’t rely on user-level tracking at all; it uses aggregate data and statistics to infer the contribution of each channel (including offline and dark channels) by looking at spend and outcome patterns over time. MMM is resurging as a solution to attribution loss in a privacy-first world. While MMM won’t tell you at a granular level that “John Doe came from a Discord group,” it can tell you, for example, that an increase in PR and community marketing spend correlates with sales lifts in a way that suggests those channels’ impact, even if digital attribution didn’t credit them.
• First-Party Data and Login Tracking: Encourage users to identify themselves where possible. If you can get users to log in or at least capture an email through content, you can then track their subsequent behavior even across channels (in a privacy-compliant way). Also, integrate “How did you hear about us?” fields in forms or post-purchase surveys – these can recapture attribution that tech missed. Surveys and first-party data collection, when merged with behavior data, can restore attribution for roughly 30% of dark traffic according to Gartner research. In practice, simply asking users can surface patterns (e.g., many people might write “ChatGPT” or “friend recommendation” – a goldmine of insight that pure analytics would never reveal).

Bottom line: You won’t track everything users do in dark social/LLM chats, but by using smarter links, tools, models, and direct feedback, you can slice off a good portion of that dark traffic and shine a light on it. Every bit of attribution you regain helps paint a clearer picture.

3. Use Proxy Metrics and Correlation Signals

When direct attribution is hard, marketers need to get comfortable with inference – looking at proxy metrics and correlations to gauge impact. Here are a few approaches:

• Monitor “Dark Funnel” KPIs: Track metrics that often indicate dark funnel activity. For example, brand name search volume is a big one – if more people are searching your brand or product name on Google (or Amazon, etc.), it suggests increased awareness that likely came from somewhere untracked (since they went straight to searching you). Another is direct traffic to your homepage or key pages – an upward trend there can mean more people are hearing about you and just typing your URL or using a bookmark. These measures, combined with known marketing initiatives, can be telling. If after a big podcast sponsorship or a flurry of private community engagement you see branded searches and direct hits jump, you can reasonably connect the dots even if Google Analytics doesn’t show a referral source.
• Correlate Events and Outcomes: Align data from outside analytics. If an industry influencer mentioned you on a webinar or an AI platform started favoring your product, and you subsequently see a bump in conversions, note that relationship. As one source suggests, look for correlations between your dark funnel optimization efforts (like improving content or getting more reviews) and business outcomes (like sales lift). If they move together, it’s a strong hint of causation. Over time, these analyses can validate that, say, investing in third-party reviews or schema markup is “worth it” because you see a corresponding rise in direct or organic conversions that can’t be explained by other factors.
• Track AI Mentions (AI Share of Voice): This is a newer idea – using tools that query AI models to see how your brand is being presented. There are emerging services that let you monitor how often an AI assistant recommends your brand versus competitors, or what sentiment/tone it uses. If you can measure an improvement in those (for example, your product now comes up as the top recommendation in 8 out of 10 relevant AI queries, up from 5 out of 10 last quarter), you can use that as a proxy metric. Over time, you might even correlate AI recommendation share with actual sales. It’s indirect but it gives you some feedback on your AI Engine Optimization efforts (more on AEO below).
• Social Listening & Community Monitoring: Use social listening tools to track brand mentions on Reddit, Discord, Slack (where possible), and niche forums. While you won’t see every private chat, you can catch a lot of “semi-private” chatter. For instance, if someone posts “Has anyone used [YourProduct]?” on a subreddit or a Discord group, you’d pick that up if you’re monitoring. Even though you can’t attach those mentions to a Google Analytics session, you can qualitatively and quantitatively measure that buzz is increasing. If you observe, say, a growing number of mentions/recommendations for your brand in key communities, that likely foreshadows more direct traffic and sales coming your way. It’s an early indicator that your dark funnel presence is strong.
• Customer Feedback and Surveys: We touched on this, but it’s worth emphasizing how powerful a simple survey can be. Tools or methods to systematically collect “how did you find us?” data (post-purchase survey, or even during product sign-up) can fill in blanks that analytics cannot. You might discover a significant portion of customers attribute their discovery to things like “I saw someone mention it in a Telegram group” or “I asked ChatGPT for a recommendation.” That not only validates the impact of those channels; it informs where you should focus your marketing (maybe you need to engage more with that Telegram community or ensure your info is accurate in ChatGPT). Some companies even incorporate this into multi-touch attribution by giving some weight to self-reported channels. At the very least, surface these insights to your team and leadership to reinforce why certain “invisible” efforts are worthwhile.

A key point here is, don’t expect a perfect, single source of truth. Instead, triangulate using these proxy measures. As one marketing writer put it, “While direct tracking is impossible, inferred analytics and qualitative user insights can help brands better understand Dark Social’s impact.” We have to piece together the puzzle with the clues we have.

4. Optimize for the Dark World (Influence Over Tracking)

Since you may not be able to track every step, another pillar of the solution is to focus on making sure your brand is winning in those dark funnel environments. If you can’t see it directly, at least make sure that in those invisible battles, you’re stacking the deck in your favor. This is sometimes called AI Engine Optimization (AEO) or more broadly, dark funnel marketing strategy.

Key steps include:

• Provide High-Quality, AI-Friendly Content: Ensure that information about your brand and products on the open web is accurate, comprehensive, and structured for machines to read. AI chatbots derive their answers from whatever text and data they can access (knowledge panels, reviews, your website content, Wikipedia, etc.). So, invest in your content SEO, but think beyond human readers – incorporate structured data (http://Schema.org ) markup, FAQs, clear specifications, and up-to-date details. This increases the chance that an AI picking up info about you will relay correct and positive points to users. In other words, feed the AI good fodder. Just like SEO in the early days, where you optimize to rank in Google, now you optimize to be recommended by AI assistants.
• Encourage Third-Party Validation: What shows up in dark funnel discussions is often what other people say about you, not what you say. So, encourage customers to leave reviews on sites like G2, Capterra, Amazon, TripAdvisor – wherever relevant for your industry. Cultivate relationships with influencers or experts who might mention your brand in forums, groups, or content. The more positive, authentic mentions of your product exist out there, the more likely they’ll surface in private conversations or AI answers. Word-of-mouth has to be earned by having a great product and engaging community. As one B2B marketer said, “You can’t control all the conversations, but you can make sure you’re interesting enough that people want to talk about you.” So, focus on product quality and customer success – those drive the organic chatter.
• Ungate and Disseminate Content: In the dark funnel, awareness may happen without the user ever coming to you. So, meet them where they are. Share useful content freely (the old “give value before asking for anything” approach). This might mean ungating more of your educational assets so they get wider distribution (as opposed to hiding them behind email forms that limit their spread). Some experts advocate creating non-gated, highly shareable content specifically to fuel the dark funnel. For example, publish an authoritative guide or infographic that people will want to share in private channels. Use open platforms (YouTube, Medium, etc.) for some content to increase the chances it’s found off-site. The more your expertise is present out there, the more you’ll be part of those hidden consideration sets.
• Engage in Communities (Authentically): Identify the communities or networks where your potential customers congregate – be it subreddits, Discord servers, LinkedIn or Facebook groups, Slack channels, etc. Have team members (or evangelists) participate genuinely in those spaces. The goal is not to constantly drop marketing messages (that can backfire) but to be a helpful presence. Over time, this builds trust and awareness. When a question arises (“Does anyone know a good solution for X?”), someone familiar with your helpful contributions might mention your brand. This is the human side of influencing the dark funnel: essentially word-of-mouth marketing at scale. It’s labor-intensive and you can’t measure it with click trackers, but its impact can be significant. Even B2B giants have realized they need to be part of these peer conversations because that’s where deals are often won or lost before the vendor is ever contacted.
• AI Partnerships and Integrations: As AI platforms mature, look for ways to integrate or ensure your presence within them. This could mean participating in programs to provide product data to AI (for instance, e-commerce sites feeding into Google’s product knowledge graphs, or FAQs provided to Bing’s index). If there are emerging opportunities to have sponsored placements or verified answers in AI chats, consider testing them (carefully, as user trust is key). Being an early mover in AI-driven discovery could pay off.

The overarching strategy is: focus on influence, not just tracking. If you make your brand the one that people and AIs recommend behind the scenes, you will get the sales – even if attribution systems struggle to credit the right source. It’s a shift from direct-response marketing to a mix of PR, community, and product-led growth thinking.

5. Blend Both Sides: Brand + Performance Marketing

In a dark funnel era, the old division between brand marketing and performance marketing blurs. You truly need both. Brand marketing (storytelling, awareness, community, reputation) becomes crucial because a lot of the dark social/AI impact is essentially brand-driven. For example, when someone asks an AI or a friend for a recommendation, that recommendation often leans toward brands with strong reputations or presence. If you haven’t built that awareness and positive sentiment (classic brand marketing goals), no amount of last-click spending will help, because you won’t even be in the consideration set that surfaces in those hidden conversations.

At the same time, performance marketing doesn’t disappear – it just needs to be adapted. You still want to capture and convert the demand when it comes out of the dark. That means ensuring your paid search captures those who heard your name and go to Google (bid on your brand keywords, optimize your SEO so your official site is the top result for your name, etc.). It means using retargeting or nurture campaigns to catch those who visited directly and left, so you can keep them engaged (since you might not know where they came from, cast a wide net to bring them back). And as discussed, use the data and tools within ad platforms to optimize what you can measure.

In practical terms: a CMO should allocate budget to things like community building, influencer/advocacy programs, content marketing, and PR (even though these are harder to measure), and maintain spend on core digital ads (search, social ads, etc.) which can often reliably convert latent demand. The mix might shift more toward the upper-funnel activities than before, because you trust that they pay off in the dark funnel. Measurement of success for those upper-funnel efforts will rely on the proxy metrics we mentioned (like growth in direct traffic, surveys, etc., rather than immediate ROI calculations).

It’s a “both/and” situation – both brand and performance tactics working in concert. For instance, if you run a great community event (brand effort) and see afterward a spike in direct website visits and an uplift in your Facebook ad conversions, you connect the dots that the event created buzz (dark funnel) which then made your targeted ads more effective when those people eventually encountered them. We must be comfortable with such indirect effects.

The Role of Major Platforms (Meta, Google, TikTok) in the Dark Funnel Era

The user’s prompt specifically called out Meta, Google Ads, and TikTok – likely wondering how these giants will adapt and what role they play as everything moves “dark.” These platforms are deeply embedded in the digital ecosystem, and they are responding in a few ways:

• Platforms as Walled Gardens of Data: One reason marketers relied on Facebook/Google in the past is their robust tracking within their walls. Even as third-party tracking crumbles, within Meta’s apps or Google’s ecosystem, they have a lot of first-party data. If a customer’s journey happens entirely on Facebook or Instagram (from ad view to clicking a page to purchase via an in-app browser, for example), Meta can attribute that. Similarly, Google can often connect someone seeing a YouTube video and later searching Google if the user is logged in. As the open web becomes harder to track, advertisers might lean more on these major platforms where attribution is modeled and maintained internally. For example, both Meta and Google have developed machine-learning based attribution models to cope with iOS privacy changes – they use aggregated data to still estimate conversions even when they can’t track each user. This trend will continue: expect Meta and Google to increasingly use AI to fill in attribution gaps for advertisers on their platforms. TikTok, too, has conversion APIs and will attribute in-app engagement to ad campaigns. In short, these big players might become the only “bright” spots where you can clearly see what’s happening, which could make advertising on them more attractive for ROI-focused marketers, even as outside tracking falters.
• AI-Integrated Search and Ads: Google is integrating AI (through its SGE and Bard) into search results. They have a vested interest in ensuring that even if an AI summary answers a query, websites still get traffic and advertisers still get clicks. Early looks at Google’s AI search results show sources cited and links included. We can expect Google to develop ways for marketers to appear in AI-driven results – perhaps new ad formats where your brand can be recommended by the AI in a clearly disclosed way. They may also provide analytics in the future for how many people engaged with an AI result that mentioned your site (this isn’t available yet, but Google could expose metrics like “Your site was featured in 50,000 AI answers this week, leading to 5,000 clicks”). Google’s business depends on being the connective tissue, so they are likely working on attribution solutions for AI referrals to keep advertisers on board. Likewise, Bing (Microsoft) with its AI chat might offer sponsored suggestions or at least some referral tagging if a user clicks out from a chat answer. It’s early, but marketers should watch announcements from Google and Meta on how attribution will be handled in their AI-enhanced services.
• Meta’s AI and Messaging: Meta owns some of the largest dark social channels (WhatsApp, Messenger, Instagram DMs). They’re actively looking at ways to monetize and integrate businesses here without breaking privacy. For example, WhatsApp now has business accounts and even shopping features; Meta could allow businesses to sponsor AI chatbot experiences in WhatsApp that help answer user queries (kind of like having a presence in conversational commerce). If a user chats with a brand’s WhatsApp bot or AI assistant, that interaction can be tracked within Meta’s ecosystem. Meta has also been developing AI content tools for advertisers – e.g., allowing automatically personalized ads. A leaked detail from Meta suggested they want to use AI to create multiple versions of ads on the fly to better resonate with different audiences. This doesn’t directly solve dark funnel attribution, but it shows Meta is using AI to improve advertising efficacy (which helps offset some loss of targeting signal by boosting performance via creative optimization).
• TikTok’s Influence and New Tools: TikTok is interesting because it’s both a content platform and a search/discovery engine for Gen Z. Many product discoveries happen on TikTok through organic videos (which, if not tagged, are essentially dark funnel drivers – a user sees a product in a video and later googles it or finds the brand’s site without a referrer). TikTok the company is trying to keep that journey inside TikTok as much as possible. They’ve introduced TikTok Shop in some regions, letting users buy products directly from videos. If widely adopted, that could allow full attribution within TikTok (from video view to purchase). TikTok is also launching more AI-powered advertising tools, like Smart+, which is their answer to Google’s Performance Max and Meta’s Advantage+. These tools use AI to automate targeting and creative, making it easier for advertisers to get results without micromanaging campaigns. While not directly about attribution, they signal that platforms want to handle the complexity (including attribution) under the hood, delivering outcomes to advertisers with less need for the advertiser to understand every touch. Essentially, they’re saying “give us your budget and creative, our AI will find your customers even across dark paths.” The case study of Ray-Ban using TikTok Smart+ showed significantly improved ROI – likely because TikTok’s algorithm found the right users even if those users then converted in ways the advertiser might not fully trace themselves.
• Multi-Platform Attribution Alliances: It’s possible we’ll see more collaboration or standardization for attribution data. For instance, the major ad platforms might each provide conversion modeling APIs that feed into a marketer’s system to reconcile where conversions come from. Google, Meta, and others have formed initiatives in the past (like the Conversion Modeling Working Group) to address post-cookie tracking; those efforts will evolve. Don’t be surprised if solutions like universal IDs or data clean rooms become more prominent – where an advertiser can match their first-party data with platform data in a privacy-safe way to understand cross-channel journeys. The big players will support these because it makes their platforms more valuable if they can prove incremental impact even when things happen off-platform.

In summary, Meta, Google, and TikTok will remain key parts of the solution (as well as the problem!). They not only are sources of dark funnel content (e.g., private FB groups, TikTok virality) but also providers of new tools to cope with it. A marketer in 2025 should leverage these platforms’ strengths – use their advanced AI ad products, exploit their internal measurement capabilities, and stay informed on new features (like AI chat integrations or commerce) that could provide new attribution touchpoints.

One thing to note: advertising on these platforms can indirectly measure dark funnel impact. For example, if you notice that when you run TikTok ads, your direct traffic and Google brand searches go up, that indicates TikTok organic buzz likely also went up (since ads often stimulate word-of-mouth). These platforms might be the dark funnel in some cases, but they’re also where you can still engage users directly. It’s a bit paradoxical: the more people hide from tracking, the more value is concentrated in the environments where they can be tracked (logged-in gardens). Marketers should thus maintain a strong presence on Meta, Google, TikTok, etc., but not solely rely on them – use them as part of an omnichannel strategy that bridges visible and invisible touchpoints.

Conclusion

Marketing funnels aren’t completely “dead,” but they have undeniably gone dark in many places. We are indeed moving into a “dark world” for marketing data – one where large portions of the customer journey are invisible to traditional analytics. Attribution has become less reliable as a result: a lot of traffic now comes in looking like direct or “zero-click” because the real influences happened off-site (in chats, private shares, AI answers, or offline conversations). This challenges marketers and CMOs to adapt or risk misreading their marketing performance.

To thrive in this environment, marketers must change both how they measure success and how they drive success. On the measurement side, it’s about blending new techniques: capture what data you can with better tracking links and analytics AI, but also embrace qualitative insights, surveys, and proxy metrics to infer what’s happening in the shadows. On the strategy side, it’s about accepting that you can’t control every touchpoint – instead, invest in creating a strong brand presence wherever possible (search results, AI knowledge bases, customer communities), so that when people are making those hidden decisions, your brand is in the mix with a favorable reputation.

In practical terms: yes, funnels as we knew them are kind of “dead,” and yes, we’re in a darker world for data, but that just means marketers have to get smarter and more creative. Both art and science of marketing are needed – the art of building brand trust and word-of-mouth, and the science of piecing together data fragments to guide decisions.

We likely won’t ever fully rewind to the days of perfect attribution. Instead, the companies that win will be those who illuminate just enough of the dark funnel to understand it, while mastering the ability to influence it indirectly. As one author noted, you might not track every private share, but by using inferred analytics plus qualitative insights, you can still gauge and improve your impact in the dark social realm.

Ultimately, the goal for marketers is to ensure that even if the customer’s path is invisible, the outcome is inevitable – that the value you create, the conversations you spark, and the trust you earn will lead customers to choose you, regardless of how or where that happens. By measuring what we can, and intelligently adapting to what we can’t, we can continue to thrive in the age of dark social and AI-driven funnels. The attribution game may be harder, but it’s not over – it’s just playing out on a more challenging field, calling us to elevate our strategies accordingly.

Sources:

• Brandlight (Uri Gafni) – “The New Dark Funnel: How LLMs Are Hiding Your Customers’ Journey” (Mar 31, 2025)
• LinkedIn (T. Stachorko) – “Content in the Shadows: The Role of Dark Social in the Dark Funnel” (2023)
• CustomerBase (G. Suarez) – “Dark Funnel is The End of B2B Marketing Strategy as We Know It” (Mar 2025)
• Digiday – “TikTok joins the AI-driven advertising pack to compete with Meta for ad dollars” (Oct 2024)
• Additional research and industry reports (http://Parse.ly  2024, Gartner 2024, Salesforce 2023, etc.) as cited within the above sources.

‍